Some Bright Nowhere, by Ann Packer
Intriguing premise, irritating execution. ★★☆☆☆

I picked up Some Bright Nowhere after reading a positive review and noticing it was available through Libby as an audiobook. It accompanied me on airplanes, beaches, and pool decks during my recent trip to Puerto Vallarta. It certainly passed the time, but getting through it felt more like an obligation than a pleasure.
The premise is undeniably intriguing. Eliot and Claire have been married for nearly forty years. They raised two children, built a life together, and weathered Claire's long battle with cancer. As her illness enters its final stage, Eliot assumes that he will continue caring for his wife and spend her remaining days at her side. Instead, Claire drops a bombshell: she wants to spend her final weeks primarily in the company of her two closest female friends.
Eliot is devastated.
The novel then becomes an extended examination of the fallout from that decision. Claire insists on having things her way. Eliot struggles to accept it. Friends and family are pulled into the orbit of their disagreement.
The central question the novel poses is a legitimate one: Whose death is it, anyway? Does a dying person have the right to make choices that bring them comfort, even when those choices cause pain to the people who love them most?
It's a fascinating question. Unfortunately, I found the novel's exploration of it frustrating.
On some level, I understand Claire's desire. If I were facing the end of my life, I can easily imagine wanting my sister nearby. She knows me in a different way than my husband does. We share decades of history, private jokes, family memories, and a shorthand that only siblings possess. Yet I never found Claire's request nearly as self-evidently reasonable as the novel seemed to. Nor could I understand why Eliot's hurt and bewilderment were treated as something he simply needed to get over.
The problem is that neither character fully won me over. Claire struck me as surprisingly insensitive to the emotional damage she was inflicting on her husband. Eliot, meanwhile, spends much of the novel cycling through the same resentments and grievances. Rather than deepening the conflict, the story often feels as though it's treading water. Every time Claire reveals a new incident that indicates she wants time away from him, Eliot gets all freaked out. Again. We get it. She want this. He's annoyed. Enough already.
I kept waiting for an emotional breakthrough that never arrived.
Ann Packer writes well enough, and the book raises worthwhile questions about marriage, loyalty, caregiving, and death. But for me, the characters never became fully convincing, and the emotional payoff never materialized. I should have been moved by Claire's decline and Eliot's grief. Instead, I mostly found myself irritated by both of them.
Your mileage may vary. The novel clearly resonated deeply with many readers. For me, however, it was an interesting premise stretched into a story that never quite justified its length.




Comments